The current National Tuberculosis Programme (NTP)
was evolved by the NTI, Bangalore in 1962 after conducting a series
of Epidemiological, Sociological and Operational Studies. The programme
is integrated with the General Health Services (GHS). In spite of
its sound conceptual and structural foundation, the programme performance
was below expectation. Government of India had evaluated the reasons
of low performance through a study group constituted by Indian Council
of Medical Research (ICMR), in 1975 but the programme did not improve
either due to non-implementation of the recommendations of the ICMR
committee or they were not effective. The Institute of Communication,
Operations Research And Community Involvement (ICORCI), an independent
agency was asked by the Government of India to have an in depth
evaluation of NTP. The terms of reference for this evaluation
were to review the Objectives, Implementations & Expectations
of the NTP along with various factors responsible for short fall
and give recommendations to improve its performance. The evaluation
was generally through routine quarterly reports received by NTI
and information collected on the spot during the actual field visits
made by the multi disciplinary expert group of ICORCI. A total of
five states were selected. From among the total districts of these
states, nine districts were picked up by composite index methodology
and from each district, two PHCs were selected on the basis of performance.
OBSERVATIONS: About 15% of the districts
are still without DTP. There was an increase of X-ray examinations
per DTP by 1.4 times from 1981 to 1987, the percentage contribution
of PHIs to new sputum examination increased from 34 in 1981 to 72
in 1987 leading to 1.44 increase in diagnosis of cases. Sputum positivity
rate decreased from 13.6 in 1978 to 6.7 in 1987. The percentage
contribution by PHI in case detection increased from 35 in 1981
to 40 in 1987. Number of suspect cases increased 1.8 times in 1987.
There were wide variations in the X-ray positivity rates between
the states, throwing doubt about the quality of X-ray reading. Suspect
cases form 78% of all types of Tuberculosis cases diagnosed in 1987.
This was much higher than the expected 43% according to NTI studies
and indicates considerable over-diagnosis of suspect cases under
NTP. From 1986 only 27% of Tuberculosis patients had made 12 or
more monthly collections of Anti-TB drugs. It is a matter of serious
concern and the reasons have to be investigated. In 1987, only 27%
of the DTPs had a full DTC team and only 65% had DTC vehicle. This
indicates deterioration in supervision. The other factors
like lack of NTI training of DTC key personnel, Communication,
Health Education, Community Involvement and contradictory instructions
from the DTP manuals, central & state guidelines etc., influence
the performance of the programme adversely. Most of the medical
officers of the PHC wanted integration to continue. They only wanted
that the additional inputs may be provided.
RECOMMENDATIONS: Most of the recommendations
given are for improvement of the system which is essential for the
success of NTP. Some specific recommendations for NTP are also given.
Integration of health programme may be effected at district and
state levels in a phased manner. It would be desirable to have integration
with the central level also with one Director General of Health
Services monitoring all programmes in one region of the country.
A common budget for all health programmes/activities will solve
many of the problems and will be in accordance with the principles
of integration. Develop a proper two way referral system
covering all programmes and activities. Orientation training
may be given to all officers regarding budgeting, administration,
monitoring and technical aspects. A vehicle pool may be maintained
at the district level under the control of DCMO and monitored by
CMO. The Central Government may supply microscopes of good
quality instead of providing funds. Working facilities at DTCs and
PHCs may be reviewed periodically to ensure good working conditions
for efficient functioning. Local level recruitments may be made
for Health Assistants and Health Workers. A careful review of the
reasons for indiscipline, particularly at PHC level may be made
before the situation deteriorates further. The entire staff structure
and recruitment may be reviewed to provide promotional opportunities
to all categories of staff. All suspect cases may be put under observation
as per WHO recommendations instead of straight away giving them
anti TB treatment for long periods. Sputum collection by Health
Workers may be re introduced. Reasons for deviation from DTP manuals
may be investigated, particularly in STCs which are required to
train the staff as well as supervise the DTPs. Short Course Chemotherapy
may be extended to all DTPs in the country. Steps may be taken to
ensure that follow up examinations are carried out regularly and
the results recorded on treatment cards. A drug testing laboratory
may be set up in each state as proposed for the VIII plan. Procurement
of drugs may be made only from reputed firms. In order to have a
reliable monitoring, sample checks have to be carried out
to ensure the validity of the records and reports. Targets for NTP
may be withdrawn, particularly those regarding case detection to
avoid over diagnosis. A monitoring and evaluation cell headed by
a statistician may be created under the CMO to cater the needs of
all programmes. The recommendations made for improvement may be
introduced only after proper testing by field trials following operations
research methodology. Changes introduced on adhoc basis may create
more problems than are solved.
|