|
174 |
COHORT ANALYSIS OF THE TREATMENT RESULTS UNDER DISTRICT
TUBERCULOSIS PROGRAMME |
National Tuberculosis Institute, Bangalore, October
1994: National Tuberculosis Programme (NTP) is in vogue since 1962.
|
The unit of NTP is known as District Tuberculosis
Programme (DTP). The name is derived from the area, as each unit
covers a district which is geographically, administratively, politically
independent. The performance of the DTP from its inception till
1977-78 was monitored continuously by two centres, Northern Regional
Centre (NRC) and Southern Regional Centre (SRC) situated in north
and south India respectively. Later on in 1978 when these centres
were abolished, National Tuberculosis Institute (NTI) was given
the responsibility of monitoring the programme in the entire country.
NTI monitors the performance of the programme through the quarterly
and annual reports received from DTPs. The results of cohort
analysis based on treatment cards of patients under DTP, are
reported by the DTC through annual reports, which needs expertise.
As a result, not only limited number of reports are received but
also some of them are not up to the mark. Hence, it was felt to
have a base line study of cohort analysis of treatment pattern of
various categories of TB patients treated under DTPs. With the assistance
from WHO, a pilot study was carried out in two districts of Mysore
& Hassan of Karnataka State for the cohort period of Jan
Dec 1991. On the basis of District Case Index Registers, 4053
treatment cards were collected from both the DTPs, of which
3877 were considered for analysis.
Results of analysis are being given separately
for each district. In Hassan out of 1564 patients, 259 (16.5%) were
smear positive, 1256 (80.3%) suspect cases and 49 (3.1%) extra pulmonary
cases. The treatment completion rates for different categories
of patients were: smear positive treated with SR 26.2%, with
SCC 47.5%, suspect cases 23.3% and extra pulmonary 51%. In
Mysore district, there were 2313 patients. Of them, 203 (8.8%) were
smear positive, 1706 (73.8%) suspect cases and 275 (11.9%) extra
pulmonary. Treatment completion rates for smear positive treated
with SR 17%, with SCC 43.8%, X-ray suspect cases 18.8%
and extra pulmonary 24.7%. Information on outcome of treatment i.e.,
cure rates, deaths etc., could not be collected due to incomplete
recordings on the treatment cards. It could be concluded that a
very small percentage of smear positive cases were detected. Treatment
completion rates were very poor for all the categories of patients.
There was no difference in the treatment completion rates obtained
from the study and reported by these centres to NTI through annual
report.
|
KEY WORDS: COHORT ANALYSIS, DTP, TREATMENT COMPLETION
RATE. |
175 |
A COMPARISON OF PERFORMANCE OF X-RAY CENTRES, MICROSCOPY
CENTRES & REFERRING CENTRES UNDER DISTRICT TUBERCULOSIS PROGRAMME |
R Rajalakshmi & MV Jaigopal: Indian J Tub 1995,
42, 215-20. |
District Tuberculosis Programme (DTP) was formulated
in 1962 with one of the objectives of diagnosing maximum number
of tuberculosis patients. The rural health institutions implemented
as Peripheral Health Institutions (PHIs) are expected to play a
major role. The PHIs according to the type of facilities available,
are classified into X-ray Centres (XCs), Microscopy Centres (MCs)
and Referring Centres (RCs). While all centres provide treatment,
XCs offer chest X-ray and sputum microscopy examination; MCs offer
only sputum microscopy and from RCs sputum slides are prepared and
referred for further examination to DTC/XCs/MCs. The performance
of DTP activities at PHIs are collectively reported. Hence, it was
worth studying categorywise performance of PHIs, which may help
in developing strategy for improvement in the performance of the
National Tuberculosis Programme.
OBSERVATIONS : DTP is operational in 390
(89%), out of the 438 districts in the country. Of the 17,850 implemented
PHIs, 2390 (13.7%), 8717 (48.8%) and 6740 (37.8%) are functioning
as XCs, MCs and RCs respectively. In all, 208 DTP reports for October
to December 1993 quarter received at National Tuberculosis Institute,
were analysed. Reporting efficiency of XCs, & MCs was 85%, whereas
of RCs, 54%. Of the 33.1 million self reporting outpatients belonging
to various PHIs, 35% attended XCs, 43% MCs and 22% RCs. Of the total
sputum examinations performed during the study period, XCs examined
39%, MCs 52% and RCs 9%. Selection of chest symptomatics worked
out to 1.8% for XCs, 2.0% for MCs and 0.7% for RCs. Out of the total
28,654 smear positive cases diagnosed, 56% were detected by XCs,
37% by MCs and only 7% by RCs. It is seen that XCs diagnosed 56%
of the total cases by doing 39% of the total sputum examinations.
The sputum positivity rate at XCs is 7.8% which is almost double
that of 3.8% at the MCs and 4.4% at RCs.
Sputum Examination Efficiency (SEE) and Case Detection
Efficiency (CDE) (percentage of achievement compared with expectation)
have also been compared according to the category of PHIs. SEE of
XCs & MCs were 70% & 78% respectively as compared to only
26.5% in RCs. The CDE of XCs, MCs & RCs were 69.1%, 36.9% and
14.1% respectively. It is observed that XCs are working satisfactorily
as 35% of the total out patients attend the XCs, their reporting
efficiency being 85%, sputum examination efficiency 70% and sputum
positivity rate 7.8%, indicating good performance, while MCs
had a low sputum positivity rate of 3.8%, suggesting that there
is a large scope for qualitative improvement in Case-finding activity.
While RCs cater to about 20% of the total out patients had
poor performance on all account and need a great deal of technical
supervision.
|
KEY WORDS: DTP, PERFORMANCE, PHIs CATEGORY,
CASE-FINDING. |
|
|